All About Universal Basic Income in India

All About Universal Basic Income in India

In India, the idea of UBI has stirred quite the debate, with many lauding it as a potential solution to poverty and economic inequality.

It’s a radical shift from traditional welfare systems, offering an unconditional safety net to all citizens.

In this article, we’re going to delve into seven key aspects of Universal Basic Income in India.

We’ll explore its potential benefits, the challenges it poses, and what its implementation could mean for the country’s economy and its citizens.

1. Rising interest in UBI in India

India’s interest in Universal Basic Income has been fueled by several factors. One of the primary reasons is the increasing concern over economic inequality.

Despite significant strides in economic growth, the gap between India’s rich and poor continues to widen. UBI is seen as a potential tool to bridge this gap and ensure a basic standard of living for all citizens.

Additionally, the existing welfare system in India is often criticized for being inefficient and riddled with corruption.

The implementation of UBI could bypass these issues by providing direct financial support to all citizens, thus eliminating the need for complex bureaucracy.

The COVID-19 pandemic has also played a significant role in fostering discussions around UBI.

With millions losing their jobs and struggling to make ends meet, the idea of a guaranteed income has become increasingly appealing.

Finally, there’s also an ongoing global conversation around UBI that India is part of.

Countries like Finland and Canada have conducted UBI experiments, and their experiences are being closely watched by policymakers worldwide, including in India.

While these factors have stimulated interest in UBI, it’s crucial to note that implementing such a system in India would be a complex process with several challenges to consider.

2. Challenges in implementing UBI in India

Implementing Universal Basic Income in India would be a significant undertaking, with several challenges to consider. The most prominent among these is the financial burden it would place on the government.

Financing a UBI that provides a meaningful income to all Indian citizens would require a substantial allocation of resources.

In a country like India, where government resources are already stretched thin across various sectors, such an endeavor could lead to financial strain. It could potentially result in cutbacks in other vital areas like healthcare, education, or infrastructure development.

Another challenge lies in determining the amount of the UBI.

The income should be sufficient to cover basic needs, but how do we define what constitutes ‘basic needs’? The cost of living varies widely across India’s diverse regions, making it challenging to set a standard UBI amount.

Furthermore, there’s the issue of identifying recipients. While UBI is meant for all citizens, implementation would require a robust system for citizen identification and bank account accessibility.

Given the digital divide and lack of banking access in many parts of rural India, this could pose a significant hurdle.

Lastly, there’s the concern about inflation. Economists worry that pumping money into the economy through UBI could lead to increased demand for goods and services, causing prices to rise.

This could potentially negate the benefits of UBI by reducing purchasing power.

These challenges highlight that while UBI is an appealing idea, its practical implementation in India would require careful planning and consideration.

3. Potential benefits of UBI in India

Despite the challenges, there are several potential benefits to implementing Universal Basic Income in India. Firstly, it could significantly reduce poverty.

By providing a guaranteed income, UBI ensures that no citizen is without the means to meet their basic needs. This could uplift millions from poverty and provide a safety net for those at risk of falling into poverty.

Secondly, UBI could streamline the welfare system. Currently, India’s welfare system includes a myriad of schemes and subsidies, each with its own administrative costs and inefficiencies.

A single, direct cash transfer through UBI could simplify this system and reduce administrative costs.

Thirdly, UBI could promote economic equality. By giving every citizen the same amount of money regardless of their current wealth or status, UBI promotes a degree of income equality. This could help in addressing the vast wealth gap in India.

Finally, UBI could potentially stimulate economic growth. With more disposable income, consumer spending could increase, driving demand and potentially leading to job creation and economic growth.

However, it’s crucial to remember that these benefits hinge on successful implementation. The challenges we discussed earlier pose significant hurdles that would need to be overcome for these potential benefits to be realized.

4. UBI trials in India

India is no stranger to the concept of Universal Basic Income, with several trials conducted in recent years.

One such experiment took place in Madhya Pradesh between 2011 and 2013 by the Self-Employed Women’s Association (SEWA) and UNICEF.

In the experiment, over 6,000 individuals received a monthly cash transfer for 18 months. The results were promising.

Recipients showed improvements in nutrition, healthcare access, school enrollment rates, and even increased economic activity.

Another smaller pilot project was conducted in a tribal village in West Delhi by the Delhi government. This project provided a monthly income to families living below the poverty line.

The project reported positive outcomes, with beneficiaries spending more on food and education.

These trials give us valuable insights into the potential impact of UBI in India. However, it’s important to note that these were small-scale experiments.

Implementing UBI at a national level would present different challenges and may yield different results.

READ ALSO:

5. The Economic Survey’s view on UBI

India’s Economic Survey of 2016-17 featured a full chapter on Universal Basic Income. It highlighted UBI as a radical and compelling paradigm shift in thinking about both social justice and productive economy.

According to the survey, UBI could promote three essential elements of the constitution: equality, justice, and dignity. It could serve as an effective tool to alleviate poverty and provide social security.

The Survey made a strong case for UBI by proposing a model where every Indian above the age of 18 would receive a basic income directly into their bank accounts.

However, it also acknowledged the challenges of implementing such a scheme, particularly the concern of it being financially viable.

While the Economic Survey does not constitute policy, its inclusion of UBI indicates serious interest in the concept at the highest levels of government.

It has certainly spurred further discussions and debates around UBI in India.

6. Possible alternatives to UBI in India

While Universal Basic Income is a promising idea, it’s not the only approach being considered to address poverty and inequality in India. Other alternatives are also being explored.

One such alternative is the idea of a Negative Income Tax (NIT). This model involves a direct cash transfer to individuals whose income falls below a certain threshold.

The NIT differs from UBI as it targets low-income individuals specifically, rather than providing a uniform income to all citizens.

Another proposal is the expansion of existing social security programs. This would involve increasing the coverage and effectiveness of current welfare schemes to reach more people who need support.

Additionally, job creation programs like the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) could be expanded.

These programs not only provide income but also contribute to infrastructure development and skill enhancement.

While these alternatives may not carry the same transformative promise as UBI, they are more feasible from a fiscal standpoint and have the potential to make significant strides in poverty reduction and social security.

They represent important considerations in the ongoing discussion around welfare reform in India.

7. The future of UBI in India

The future of Universal Basic Income in India remains uncertain. While there are compelling arguments for its implementation, the financial and logistical challenges are significant.

However, even if UBI isn’t implemented in its purest form, elements of it are already being incorporated into Indian policy.

For instance, the Pradhan Mantri Kisan Samman Nidhi (PM-KISAN) scheme, which provides income support to small and marginal farmers, reflects aspects of UBI.

It’s also worth noting that the discussions around UBI have brought attention to the need for social security reform in India. They have sparked important conversations about inequality, poverty reduction, and the role of the state in providing welfare.

Whether or not UBI becomes a reality in India, these conversations are crucial for shaping a more equitable and just society. The exploration of UBI and its alternatives will continue to inform policy decisions in the years to come.

Picture of Adrian Volenik

Adrian Volenik

Related articles

Most read articles

Get our articles

The latest Move news, articles, and resources, sent straight to your inbox every month.