Without UBI, Automation Will Render Millions Jobless and Destitute

Without UBI, Automation Will Render Millions Jobless and Destitute

Without Universal Basic Income (UBI), the rise of automation threatens to leave countless individuals out of work and in financial strife. It’s a grim reality that we can no longer afford to ignore.

The rapid advancement of technology is undoubtedly transforming our world. However, without UBI, this progress could lead to widespread unemployment and poverty. It’s a sobering prospect and a cause for concern.

1. The impact of automation on the job market

The job market is constantly evolving, and automation is accelerating this evolution. It’s a force that we cannot stop, but it’s also a force that we need to understand and prepare for.

Automation, in simple terms, refers to the use of technology to perform tasks that humans previously did. This includes everything from manufacturing and data analysis to customer service and even creative roles like writing and designing.

While automation can improve efficiency and productivity, it also has a potential downside. It can lead to job displacement. This means that jobs previously done by humans are now being performed by machines or software.

Consider the Industrial Revolution. It was a time of great innovation and progress, but it also led to significant job displacement as machines took over tasks previously performed by humans.

The difference today is that automation is happening at an unprecedented pace and scale.

Here’s the worrying part: without UBI, those who lose their jobs to automation could be left without a safety net. They could find themselves struggling to make ends meet, unable to afford basic necessities like food and shelter.

The potential for widespread job displacement due to automation is why UBI is often proposed as a solution. The idea is that by providing everyone with a basic income, people who lose their jobs to automation would still have some financial security.

Without UBI, those who are displaced by automation could face severe financial hardship. They could be left scrambling to find new work in a job market where opportunities are increasingly limited due to automation.

Given the rapid pace of technological change, the potential impact of job displacement due to automation is an issue that needs urgent attention.

It’s not something we can afford to ignore or put off until later. Without UBI, the consequences could be dire for millions of people worldwide.

2. Automation’s unequal impact across sectors

Automation’s effect on employment is not uniform across all sectors. Some industries are more susceptible to automation than others. This discrepancy poses a significant threat to job security and financial stability for those working in highly automatable industries.

In industries like manufacturing, transportation, and warehousing, jobs involve routine, predictable activities. These jobs are highly susceptible to automation as robots or AI technologies can easily perform them.

However, even highly-paid, highly-skilled jobs aren’t in the clear as AI is coming for those positions too. Many thought creative jobs would never be replaced, but unfortunately, they were some of the first ones on the old chopping block.

Without UBI to provide a safety net, workers in highly automatable sectors could face a harsh reality. They may experience a sudden job loss without having an immediate alternative or solution in sight.

This scenario could lead to financial hardship and insecurity for these individuals and their families.

Moreover, the need for retraining and upskilling will be immense. Workers displaced by automation will need to acquire new skills to find employment in less automatable sectors.

This transition may not be easy or immediate, further exacerbating their financial distress.

The unequal impact of automation across sectors underscores the critical importance of UBI as a measure of protection.

By ensuring a basic income for everyone, UBI can help cushion the impact for individuals who lose their jobs due to automation and require time to pivot their career paths.

3. The potential for increased inequality

One of the most significant risks associated with automation is the potential for increased inequality. If the gains from automation are not evenly distributed, it could exacerbate income and wealth disparities.

This widening income gap could lead to increased social tension and unrest. If a large segment of the population feels left behind by technological progress, it could lead to resentment and conflict.

While UBI is not a panacea for all the challenges posed by automation, it could play a critical role in ensuring that the benefits of technological progress are shared more equitably.

4. The role of UBI in fostering societal stability

The rapid pace of automation, coupled with the absence of UBI, could potentially destabilize society. Job displacement, financial insecurity, and increased inequality can lead to social unrest and increased crime rates.

Jobs provide more than just income. They offer a sense of purpose, a place in the community, and a structured routine. When individuals lose their jobs due to automation, they lose these benefits as well.

This sudden shift can lead to feelings of worthlessness and despair, which can negatively impact mental health.

With UBI in place, individuals who lose their jobs to automation would have a financial safety net. This income could help alleviate immediate financial worries and provide some level of security during the transition period.

Moreover, UBI could also help foster societal stability by reducing income inequality and providing everyone with a basic level of financial security.

This could help reduce crime rates, improve mental health, and increase overall well-being.

UBI is not just about preventing financial hardship; it’s about preserving social harmony in an era of rapid technological change. By providing everyone with a basic income, we can ensure that everyone benefits from technological progress, not just those at the top.

5. The need for policy changes

The implementation of UBI as a response to automation-induced job displacement requires significant policy changes. Governments around the world would need to reconsider their social security systems and tax policies to fund UBI effectively.

Funding UBI is a complex issue. It would require substantial public expenditure, necessitating either increased taxes or redirection of existing government spending.

Policymakers would need to carefully consider the potential impact on the economy and the public’s willingness to accept such changes.

Moreover, the implementation of UBI would also require careful consideration of how much income to provide. The aim should be to provide enough income to ensure a basic standard of living without disincentivizing work or creating dependency.

In addition, it’s important to note that UBI is not a standalone solution. It should be complemented by other measures such as job retraining programs and education reforms to equip people with the skills needed for the jobs of the future.

6. The need for a global response

Automation and its impact on employment is a global issue. It’s not confined to a single country or region. Therefore, the response to this challenge, including the implementation of UBI, needs to be global as well.

Different countries are at different stages of automation and have varying levels of readiness for UBI. Some countries have already started piloting UBI programs, while others are still debating its merits.

The global nature of automation also means that job displacement could potentially lead to increased migration as people search for work in less automated economies. This could result in social and political tension if not managed well.

A coordinated global response to automation could help ensure that the benefits of technological progress are shared more equitably.

This could include sharing best practices for implementing UBI, coordinating policy changes, and providing support for countries that are less prepared for the transition.

The challenge of automation is daunting, but it’s not insurmountable. With thoughtful policy-making, including the implementation of UBI, we can ensure that the rise of automation benefits everyone, not just those at the top.

Picture of Adrian Volenik

Adrian Volenik

Related articles

Most read articles

Get our articles

The latest Move news, articles, and resources, sent straight to your inbox every month.